Star Wars: Episode I- The Phantom Menace 3D

Since this site didn’t exist when any of the Star Wars films were released, I have never given one a formal review. I am a fan of all six. Yes, you heard right, even the prequels. So watching Star Wars: Episode I- The Phantom Menace 3D is much less of a chore for me than other critics I have read. The film’s main storyline revolves around two Jedi Knights (Liam Neeson and Ewan McGregor) who are sent to aid in negotiations between the planet Naboo and the Trade Federation who set up a blockade surrounding it. Though as they search for a resolution, the Jedi are faced with the emergence of their ancient enemy, the Sith.

While many point the finger at the film for being a complete failure, the actual flaw comes with only portions of the script. When Anakin Skywalker is introduced, the quality of dialogue drops instantly. Jake Lloyd doesn’t do the subpar writing any favors, but it is clear that George Lucas could have used some help with learning how children speak and present themselves. Neeson’s contribution as rebellious Jedi, Qui Gon Jinn is an often overlooked aspect of the story. He never falters even when Lloyd and Natalie Portman are drowning around him. He also gives one of the better complete performances as a Jedi throughout the entire series. The character is flawed and cocky, but still aware of his position in society. He tries to free Anakin and Shmi (Pernilla August). But he is not willing to go that extra mile and guarantee both their freedom.

Unknown to me before screening, this re-release is an extended edition, which does make some scenes too long. The one that stood out is the Pod Race. It is full of excitement and very impressive in the theater, but it brings the pace to a screeching halt and showcases mostly characters that don’t exist outside of this scene. For the die-hard fans, it would be the equivalent to the bounty hunters in Empire Strikes Back being showcased for half an hour. It would be cool, but not necessary.  And since I’m pretty sure my theater’s lenses were out of focus, the 3D added nothing to it for me.

Now to the one moment even the most fickle Star Wars fans latch onto, the lightsaber duel. With John Williams’ epic “Duel of the Fates” playing, Darth Maul (Ray Park) dominates Obi-Wan and Qui Gon with his double-bladed lightsaber before being cut in half. Awesome choreography, three of the film’s best characters, but why didn’t any of us ever notice how short it is. Split up by Ananakin’s space battle, Queen Amidala’s pursuit of the Viceroy and the Gungans fighting the droids, the lightsaber duel is only a few minutes long. It is likely still the best duel in the series though.

So to all those traditionalists, give The Phantom Menace some credit. It is meant for a younger audience and introduces Qui Gon and Darth Maul. There is a quality space battle and lightsaber duel in addition to unveiling the long dreamed about Jedi Council. Honestly, you’re the only ones still talking about Jar Jar Binks. We all let it go when Luke kisses his sister. Just move on.

Each film earns either zero, a half or a full arrow in five categories. The categories are Acting, Writing/Directing, Emotion, Innovation and Overall Impression. The arrows are added up to equal the full score.